If you’re looking for the usual mansion style article…. Don’t be looking here. This is the Telenovela style…with scandal, divorce, money, greed and status.
I’m going to give you true life drama on 3 historic mansions in Newport Rhode Island; The Breakers, The Marble House and Rosecliff.
Yes, the mansions are all beautiful, there are many articles about that… but do you know the dirt?
The “Breakers” mansion in Newport Rhode Island, is the summer home of the Vanderbilts. Before we get into more about the mansion, let’s talk about where the money came from to build this amazing mansion.
The patriarch of the family (the money maker), Cornelius Vanderbilt or nicknamed as “the Commodore” started the Vanderbilt’s fortune. The Commodore acquired this nickname because he was fiercely competitive and ruthless in business and really not very nice. He borrowed $100 from his mother to purchase a steamship; he took the ship and grew the business to a fleet of steamships. Later in life he sold the fleet to purchase a small railroad; that began the journey into acquiring more railroad companies. Because he was so aggressive in business, it is said that he had many enemies. The Commadore was known as a “robber baron” which was a term used for someone who uses exploitation practices to gain wealth. He amassed a huge fortune during his life and when he passed away, he left a whopping 100-million dollar estate.
Cornelius married his cousin Sophia…what ??Cousin??...he sure did! Together they had 13 children in 15 years. History reports that he wasn’t very nice to his wife and children, his was consumed with work. He was not involved with his children much and very harsh and critical of his wife and children. History reports that he had little to do with his wife after her childbearing years were over. Hmmm... that’s the thanks she gets for giving birth to his 13 children? Sophia died of natural causes in 1868. In 1869, at age 73, he married another cousin, Frank Crawford (yes, female) who was 34…40 years younger than him!! She was younger than 7 of his 12 living children. He didn’t wait very long, did he? They did not have any children together. Cornelius passed away in 1877 at the age of 82.
It was, Cornelelius Vanderbilt II, who built the Breakers Mansion in Newport RI as a summer home. The breakers was actually built twice as the first home caught fire and was rebuilt. Unfortunately, he only got to enjoy 4 summers at the Breakers before he had a stroke and was unable to spend summers in Newport; later he had another stroke and died in 1899 at age 56.
Corneleus Vanderbilt II, had 5 children with Alice Claypoole. The children were: Cornelius Vanderbilt III, Gertrude, Alfred Gwynne and Gladys Moore and Reginald Claypoole. Apparently Corneleus II was a lot like his grandfather, and was referred to as a “joyless man who rarely smiled”. In 1896, the son, Corneleus III married Grace Wilson against his parents’ wishes. This proved to be a financially devastating move as his father was going to leave him 37 million upon his death. However, when Corneseus II died at age 56 of a cerebral hemorrhage, had changed his will to give his son, only 1.5 million instead. Thus, he was dis-Graced, ok, bad joke. The other children received approximately 7 million. The uneven distribution of inheritance between the two older sons apparently left bad feelings between the once close brothers. To try to make things better between them, Alfred offered brother Cornelius II an additional 6 million to try to reconcile. They never really reconciled.
Second son, Alfred Gwenn Vanderbilt inherited 37 million instead of his older brother. In 1901 Alfred married Elsie French in Newport Rhode Island. They had a son William Henry Vanderbilt.
Dirt alert….Elsie filed for divorce in 1908 because she found out about Alfred’s adultery. He was seeing the wife of a Cuban diplomat, Agnes, aboard his private railroad car. The divorce from Elsie cost him 10 million. Agnes was divorced by her husband and ultimately committed suicide by poison in a hotel room in 1914.
Alfred married again in 1911 to Margaret Emerson Smith Hollins McKim. She was a divorcee herself. Her previous husband was abusive and a drunk. He and Margaret had 2 children. Alfred had booked his passage on the 1912 Titanic, but at the last minute he cancelled his voyage. Wow that was a smart move!
Alfred’s luck didn’t hold out though because he was on board a ship in 1915 when it was hit by a German torpedo and it sunk, taking Alfred to his grave. Accounts of this event indicate that Alfred took off his own life jacket and place it on a woman without saying a word and walked away. This was an amazing gesture since Alfred couldn’t swim. Alfred went down with the ship and his body was never found. Ok, do we forgive him for adultery?
Alfred’s oldest son, William Henry Vanderbilt III, received 5 million and his wife Margaret received 8 million. The other children Alfred Gwynne, Jr. and George Washington Vanderbilt III, received the rest. More dirt: Brother to Alfred Gwenn, Reginald Claypoole was an interesting character. Reggie married Gloria Morgan. He was the father to Gloria Vanderbilt and the maternal grandfather to Anderson Cooper. Reggie was a gambler. It’s said that Reggie inherited 5 million; but gambled most of that away. On one occasion he went to the New York Casino and lost $70,000 in one night. Later it was found that he was in dept to the Casino for $300,000. Oh, check this out: There was more scandal with Reggie when upon his death, his sister Gertrude sued for custody for his daughter Gloria. A bit of backstory… Gloria Morgan liked the lavish life and after Reggie’s death she lived on the interest payments of Little Gloria’s inheritance. Gloria moved back to Europe where her twin sister lived (her twin lived as a mistress to Edward, Prince of Wales). When Little Gloria got tonsillitis, she took her back to the US for care and left her with the Aunt Gertrude while she returned to Europe for months. Gertrude had Gloria’s interest payments cut in half. Gloria then returned to the US to get her daughter back and Gertrude said, no way and filed for custody based on Gloria being an unfit mother. In 1934 the court trail started. Little Gloria was only 10 during this battle. Ultimately, after weeks of testimony Gertrude was awarded custody of Little Gloria.
I could go on with the family history and genealogy of the Vanderbilts, but it would be too long for this article, but believe me, its super interesting reading.
The Marble House was built in 1892 for 11 million. William Vanderbilt had given it to his wife Alva for her 39th birthday. Unfortunately, she divorced him 3 years later after 20 years of marriage and 3 children. Now Alva wasn’t waiting to move on, the very next year she married Oliver Hazard Perry Belmont and moved into his mansion. Apparently, Oliver gave Alva his castle for a wedding present… not to shabby. Alva moved back to the Marble House after Oliver passed in 1908.
Alva became a political voice for the women’s movement to get “the vote” and in 1914 she arranged a massive rally at the Marble House. She hosted 2,000 people at the rally in Newport. She let women in free, but charged the men $2 each. She worked for women’s rights her entire life/right up until her death at the age of 80. Dirt alert. Alva wasn’t the most liked individual in social circles for a couple reasons… her money was “new” money and she was a divorcee. She fought to overcome this stigma and in the end she did succeed.
In 1895 before she was divorced, she and her husband arranged marriage for her their daughter, Consuelo. Consuelo was only 18 years old at the time. They committed her hand to the 9th Duke of Marlborough, Charles Spencer Churchill. He was 10 years older than Consuelo. History reads that Consuelo was adamantly opposed to this because she was in love with another. Alva kept her imprisoned at the Marble House for the entire 6 months before her wedding. She also told Consuelo that she would commit suicide if she didn’t follow through with the marriage. Talk about a manipulative mother!
Consuelo did follow through with the marriage. The marriage lasted 30 years with 15 living separately from her husband.
Another very interesting story about Alva is how she made her way into society. It starts with another character of Newport, Mrs. William Astor. Mrs. Astor comes from “old money” and for 25 years she hosted an extravagant party each summer. This party was limited to 400 people who were the highest of society in the opinion of Mrs. Astor. Everyone wanted to be on the list called “the 400”. The Vanderbilts never made this list. Then in 1883 Mrs. Alva Vanderbilt had a great idea and decided to throw a very extravagant costume ball and invited 1200 people…. But she intentionally did not send an invitation to Mrs. Astor. Mrs. Astor was obviously very taken back that she was not invited to this party. Mrs. Astor felt she needed to be there because her daughter Carrie was making her debut into society this year…. So, she sent a calling card to Mrs. Vanderbilt, which apparently buried the hatchet and then from that point on the Vanderbilts were accepted into Mrs. Astors’ high society circle. Needless to say, after that strategic by Mrs. Astor, they received an invitation to the ball and all were happy.
The Rosecliff House was completed in 1902 and owned by Mr. & Mrs. Herman Oelrich. He passed away from a heart attack only 4 years after the mansion was finished. The real dirt here involves the architect who designed the Rosecliff, Stanford White. He was a pretty interesting character. He was known for having flings with actresses and when he saw 16-year old Evelyn Nesbit in a play, he convinced her mother to allow her to attend a lunch at his apartment with 3 other girls. From this point on it began a 5-year love affair. Eventually,
Evelyn eventually married a rich playboy, Harry Thaw, who was a very jealous individual. Evelyn and Harry returned a year later and it was Stanford White who made it known that he wanted Evelyn back. Evelyn had no idea what she was doing when she told Harry about Stanford intentions to get her back.
On June 15, 1906 Harry Thaw walked up to Stanford’s table at a musical show and shot him 3 times in the head. Wow, love will make you do crazy stuff, but this is insane!
During the trial of Thaw, the first trial reached a hung jury and the second trial resulted in a verdict of “innocent on the grounds of insanity”. Thaw was sentenced to an insane asylum in 1906. In 1913 he escaped to Canada and was returned to the asylum. He was released in 1915 and pronounced “sane”. Apparently, he was not sane because in 1917 he kidnapped a young man of 19 years old and beat him unconscious in his hotel room. Back to the asylum for Thaw for 7 more years. Once more pronounced “sane”. This time he moved to Miami beach and lived until the age of 76 and passed of a heart attack. I would say he was misdiagnosed as "sane", wow.
How many times have we said to ourselves “If I were rich… life would be so much easier”. So, it seems that money can bring you some benefits, but not everyone can say money made their lives better. Keep these interesting lives in mind when you visit the Mansions in Newport Rhode Island.